Showing posts with label Crime and Punishment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Crime and Punishment. Show all posts

Tuesday, July 01, 2008

Creative Punishment

Ked and I were driving home from running some errands this evening when we passed the music store where Ked bought his guitar, and a few other instrumental diversions. The folks who work there are nice, and take time to give good service, and have given us fair prices. So, it rather irritated us to see that some brat with a spray can had tagged their delivery van. Tagged--what a lovely euphemism, like some innocent children are playing a harmless game--what I really mean is vandalized. I know a lot of people don't think this is a big deal. Kids will be kids, and they need "creative" outlets. It's really just art on someone else's canvas, right? No big deal. Thing is, though, now the store is going to have to pay to have the van repainted, or have an insurance company pay for it, likely causing a rate increase, which means it will be more difficult for them to give the next guitar purchaser a good deal. These property crimes do cost people time and money, and not just rich people who "can afford it," but they are so low on the priority list that, even if the little creative geniuses get caught there's not much to stop them from grabbing another can of Krylon and heading back out to express themselves all over someone else's vehicle or building.

I'm thinking that our society needs to hand out a little "creative" punishment, something to maybe, possibly deter the less hardened public artists before they develop a habit of vandalism--a return to good old-fashioned shame. My idea for implementing tagger shame is this: tag them back. I propose that anyone who is caught tagging be tattooed on the forehead with an emblem of the court's choosing. Now, I realize that some taggers would wear this as a badge of honor, and getting their first forehead tat would become something of a rite of passage, so I propose the judge should make it as mortifying a mark as is humanly possible. Tough guys who are already covered over with snakes and daggers need a change of pace. Hello Kitty would do nicely, or, better yet, Barney. How about a nice big purple dinosaur smack in the middle of their forehead? To make it truly special, the judge could add lyrics like:

I tagged you
They caught me
My sentence was this Barney

I think it has a nice ring to it, don't you? I don't even think this could be classified as cruel and unusual punishment. The kid's already proven he likes art, and he's got no problem with someone taking a little "creative license" with someone else's property. The judge is only expressing himself for a little while--say, five years. After that the tagger can have the tat removed, at his own pain and expense, of course. I like it. After all, deterrence is the art of producing in the mind of the tagger the fear to spray. (Name that movie.) Too harsh? Okay, you have any better ideas? Leave 'em in the comments. I'm all eyes.

Friday, January 19, 2007

Huh...

What do you think of this? It's a Detroit News story, by Jennifer Chambers, about a boy who killed somebody at the age of 11, was tried as an adult, convicted at 13, went into juvenile detention, and now, at 21, has been released and is being given two years free rent and a college education, courtesy of the taxpayers of Michigan. Read the whole thing. There are lots of details clear through the end of the article, and I'm curious whether those details influence your opinion of how this story, this case--this young man's life--is playing out. I'm also curious what you think about his wardrobe and his career aspirations. Do they affect your perspectives on this case, or are they non-relevant and frivolous things to notice? I don't usually just toss something out there for you to read without giving my take on the matter, for good or ill, but I'm really interested in finding out what other people think of this, and want you to read it cold, uninfluenced by anybody else's spin, including mine.

Please, do come back and let me know what you think. I know most people who come to the Meow don't comment, and it's left to a handful of people who know me personally to give me any feedback. It's understandable--I am the same way myself. I very seldom comment on other people's blogs, but I really am interested in your opinion, so if you find yourself with anything to say (as long as it's civil), feel free to trot on back here and spout off. It's an open invitation.

Hat tip: Instapundit